add HDPE water pipeline and water booster pump#277
Conversation
|
Hi @euronion :) |
|
Yes, I'll review. Next time feel free to ping me with the PR as soon as you feel like it is ready for review. :) |
euronion
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Thanks for the contribution, see the comments below and let me know if you have any question!
| HDPE water pipeline,investment,2023,1588,EUR/(m^3-H2O/h)/km,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf -> Based on pipe diamter 171.65mm and 16 Bars with flow 34.71 kg/s. Considered mass flow rate for 1000 MW Electrolyzer",High-density polyethylene (HDPE) water pipeline cost | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,FOM,2023,5,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,lifetime,2023,50,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
-
Please rename it to "water pipeline HDPE", i.e. that the name reflects broader category -> diameter -> material details. So some of the info that you put in the details should also go into the name
-
Can you add the figure where you extracted the data from in the report? (Probably figure 4-7?) and the date when you accessed the publication.
-
The currency year should be 2022 instead of 2023, can you confirm/check?
-
Are there any insights about the technology year of this data, whether this is from 1981 (like the pump station data)? Else we can keep it as 2023
| HDPE water pipeline,investment,2023,1588,EUR/(m^3-H2O/h)/km,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf -> Based on pipe diamter 171.65mm and 16 Bars with flow 34.71 kg/s. Considered mass flow rate for 1000 MW Electrolyzer",High-density polyethylene (HDPE) water pipeline cost | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,FOM,2023,5,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| HDPE water pipeline,lifetime,2023,50,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,investment,2023,4775,EUR/kW,2023,"Calculated based on HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf",Cost of water booster pump per horsepower |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Similar points as for the technology above:
- rename to something like "water pipeline booster pump"
- Exact location where the info is taken from the publication (I couldn't locate the origin of the data from the pub)
- It seems like the publication uses a formula with a scaling exponent != 1, so if you make an assumption on the HP of the pump, add this assumptions and ideally also the calculation to the details.
- Check technology (1981?) and currency year (2022)
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi @doneachh and @euronion . I was the one working on this for the PR. So the source of the costs come from the formula (17) in : https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf
And the original sourcce of the formula comes from this report: https://www.countyofmonterey.gov/home/showdocument?id=18882
Where the 15570 USD are from 1981. So I used this formula to convert this number with a constant inflation of 2%:
Pump investment in millions Eur
invest_pumping_station = pump_station_cost_kw( power_kw=power_kW, usd_to_eur=snakemake.params.costs["default_exchange_rate"], a=35768, # 15570 # 35768 with inflation 2% 1981 till 2023 b=0.558, )
And the pump_station_cost_kw function is:
def pump_station_cost_kw(power_kw, usd_to_eur, a=35768, b=0.558):
Calculate pump station investment cost from installed power in kW. Parameters: ----------- power_kw : float or array Installed pump power in kW. a : float Cost factor in Eur/HP (default 35768). Source: Inflation a2023=15570(1.02)**42≈35,768 USD/HP in https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf). b : float Scaling exponent (default 0.558) Source: 1+b = 1-0.442 in https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf). usd_to_eur : float Conversion rate from USD to EUR . Returns: -------- cost_eur : float or array Pump station cost in million EUR. # Convert kW to HP power_hp = power_kw / 0.7457 # Cost formula in USD cost_usd = a * (power_hp ** b) # Convert to EUR cost_eur = cost_usd * usd_to_eur # Return cost in million EUR return cost_eur / 1e6
So technology (1981) and currency year (2023)
| water booster pump,FOM,2023,2,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,lifetime,2023,30,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", |
| water booster pump,investment,2023,4775,EUR/kW,2023,"Calculated based on HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf",Cost of water booster pump per horsepower | ||
| water booster pump,FOM,2023,2,%/year,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,lifetime,2023,30,years,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", | ||
| water booster pump,efficiency,2023,0.765,per unit,2023,"HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants, https://hypat.de/hypat-wAssets/docs/new/publikationen/HYPAT_WP_Water-Supply-for-Electrolysis-Plants.pdf", No newline at end of file |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Efficiency is not clear for this technology.
Minimum: Add to the details what the efficiency unit is
Ideally: Change the unit to something more clear, maybe m3 water per kWh or something?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi @euronion . The efficiency here is taken from the same source by multiplying the motor efficiency wiith the pump efficiency: 0.85 x 0.9=0.765
I guess we can consider the unit to be m3 water per kWh
Co-authored-by: Johannes HAMPP <42553970+euronion@users.noreply.github.com>
Closes # (if applicable).
Changes proposed in this Pull Request
Adding costs for HDPE water pipelines and pumps -> needed for integration of desalination and water management in pypsa-earth
Checklist
doc.environment.yaml(if applicable).doc/release_notes.rstof the upcoming release is included.